レポート · 速報
China, first week: ExpressVPN cut-offs, WARP failures
時点で、浙江省の中国移動の家庭用ブロードバンドでテストしているVPN 8件のうち5件が接続不可です:Tor、hide.me Free、Tor (Snowflake)、Proton VPN Free、ExpressVPN。
公開 · テスト期間 〜 · テスト方法 v2
コメント
Our first week of tests from China Mobile home broadband in Zhejiang, during the National Day holiday. Every 2 hours we connect each VPN with its official app; under method v2 a test passes only if the tunnel keeps carrying traffic to Google, which does not open on this line without a VPN. Tests before 5 October were scored again with method v2.
ExpressVPN: connects, then the tunnel is cut
ExpressVPN (paid by us, tested since 5 October) passed none of its 14 tests on 5 and 6 October. The app connects, then the tunnel stops carrying traffic within seconds; method v2 counts that as a failure. The cut-off figure below counts the tests in which it connected first.
Cloudflare WARP: failures since 6 October
Cloudflare WARP passed 9, 8, 10 and 11 of 12 tests on 2 to 5 October, and 5 of 12 on 6 October. It was Unstable from 04:30 CST on 6 October, Down from 14:30 to 20:25 CST, then Working, and Unstable again from 02:25 CST on 7 October. Our tests do not show whether this is blocking or a network fault.
The other VPNs
- Windscribe Pro (paid by us, tested since 5 October) was Working all along: 12 of 12 tests on 6 October.
- Windscribe Free was Down most of the week: Unstable for about six hours on 3 and on 6 October, and again from 06:30 CST on 7 October.
- Tor passed a single test, on 5 October.
- Tor (Snowflake), hide.me Free and Proton VPN Free passed no test from 1 to 6 October.
How we test: method.
VPN別の結果
| 順位 | VPN | 最新の状態 | 接続成功率 | 接続後に切断 | 夜の速度 | 最長の利用可期間 | 最長の接続不可 | 状態の変化 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cloudflare WARP無料 | 不安定 | 70% 47/67 | 0 | 26 Mbps 6回 | 38時間 | 5.9時間 | 12 |
| 2 | Windscribe Free無料 | 不安定 | 8% 10/131 | 0 | — | — | 2.5日 | 5 |
| 3 | Tor無料 | 接続不可 | 1% 1/67 | 0 | — | — | 4.0日 | 2 |
| — | hide.me Free無料 | 接続不可 | 0% 0/67 | 0 | — | — | 5.4日 | 0 |
| — | Tor (Snowflake)無料 | 接続不可 | 0% 0/67 | 0 | — | — | 5.4日 | 0 |
| — | Windscribe Pro有料 | 利用可 | 95% 20/212026-10-05から | 0 | 17 Mbps 2回 | 37時間 | — | 0 |
| — | Proton VPN Free無料 | 接続不可 | 0% 0/65 | 0 | — | — | 5.4日 | 0 |
| — | ExpressVPN有料 | 接続不可 | 0% 0/192026-10-05から | 7 | — | — | 32時間 | 0 |
状態の変化
- Cloudflare WARP
- 利用可 → 不安定
- 不安定 → 利用可
- 利用可 → 不安定
- 不安定 → 利用可
- 利用可 → 不安定
- 不安定 → 利用可
- 利用可 → 不安定
- 不安定 → 利用可
- 利用可 → 不安定
- 不安定 → 接続不可
- 接続不可 → 利用可
- 利用可 → 不安定
- Windscribe Free
- 接続不可 → 不安定
- 不安定 → 接続不可
- 接続不可 → 不安定
- 不安定 → 接続不可
- 接続不可 → 不安定
- Tor
- 接続不可 → 不安定
- 不安定 → 接続不可
- hide.me Free
- 期間中ずっと接続不可
- Tor (Snowflake)
- 期間中ずっと接続不可
- Windscribe Pro
- 期間中ずっと利用可
- Proton VPN Free
- 期間中ずっと接続不可
- ExpressVPN
- 期間中ずっと接続不可
国慶節の連休(2026-10-01〜2026-10-07)
| 順位 | VPN | 状態 | 2026-10-01〜2026-10-07 | 残りの期間 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cloudflare WARP | 70% 47/67 | — | ||
| Windscribe Free | 8% 10/131 | — | ||
| Tor | 1% 1/67 | — | ||
| hide.me Free | 0% 0/67 | — | ||
| Tor (Snowflake) | 0% 0/67 | — | ||
| Windscribe Pro | 95% 20/21 | — | ||
| Proton VPN Free | 0% 0/65 | — | ||
| ExpressVPN | 0% 0/19 | — |
テスト回線
- から0.4時間、テスト用PCがオフライン
テスト内容の変更
- · サイト
- Tested in China is live: VPN apps are tested every 2 hours from China Mobile home broadband in Zhejiang.
- · 測定方法
- Method v1: Connect, tunnel proof via www.google.com/generate_204, latency, services, speed, cold sign-in.
- · 測定方法
- Status rule: one failed test in 6 hours no longer makes a VPN Unstable when the latest test passed, and a status changes only after two test rounds agree.
- · 測定方法
- Tested in the app’s default automatic connection mode instead of a fixed protocol.
- · サイト
- New page: eSIM vs VPN in China.
- · サイト
- Free plans are named as such, for example Proton VPN Free, so a result is not read as covering the paid plan.
- · 新規測定
- Testing started (official Linux app, paid by us).
- · 新規測定
- Testing started (Android app in its default automatic mode, paid by us). Results are kept apart from Windscribe Free.
- · 訂正
- Runs from 2026-10-05 08:43 UTC (16:43 CST) were recorded as Windscribe Free but used our account after its upgrade to Pro. They now count for Windscribe Pro.
- · 測定方法
- Daily check without a VPN: whether each VPN's website, app download and sign-in server open from China.
- · サイト
- New pages: event log, Request a test, Get your VPN tested, and privacy.
- · 測定方法
- Method v2: A connection test now also fails when the VPN connects but stops carrying traffic within seconds: at least 5 of 8 further requests to Google must get through. All earlier tests were scored again with this rule.
- · 測定方法
- Speed tests leave out the first second, which only warms up the connection. Services that answer but are not available in the VPN's country (ChatGPT, Netflix) are now shown as such instead of as working.
- · サイト
- A Down VPN whose latest test round came out better is marked Recovering; its status changes if the next round does too.
テスト方法
各VPNの公式アプリ(Androidアプリ、Linuxアプリ)で、浙江省の中国移動の家庭用ブロードバンドから2時間ごとに接続しました。VPN経由でGoogleが開き、その後のリクエストも通れば成功です。成功率は期間全体にテスト方法v2を適用し、状態は当時サイトに表示したものです。
時点の数値です。更新ごとにその時点の数値を残し、再計算はしません。
測定方法の詳細